Stop Announcing. Start Talking. Social Media for Musicians

8 November 2023

Here's a little experiment.

Take a look at the last ten things you posted on social media. How many of them were actually about your audience?


If you're an independent musician, I'm willing to bet there were a few familiar faces.

  • New single out Friday.
  • Tickets on sale now.
  • Here's a clip from last night's gig.
  • Listen to my latest song.


And, of course, the occasional reminder that your new single is still available, just in case everybody missed the previous seventeen announcements.


There's nothing wrong with any of those posts.

But if that's all you're sharing, there's something missing.

A conversation.

And I think this is one of the biggest opportunities independent musicians overlook when it comes to social media.

Active vs passive content

I find it useful to divide social media content into two broad categories.


Passive content tells people something. Active content invites them to participate.


They're not official marketing classifications, and plenty of posts fall somewhere between the two. But they're useful ways of thinking about what you're putting out into the world.


Let's start with passive content.

Imagine you're a musician announcing a new single.

You post the artwork with the caption:

"My new single is out now. Listen on Spotify!"

Perfectly reasonable.

You're telling people something they might want to know.

But you're not giving them much of a reason to respond.


Now imagine posting a short video explaining that the song was inspired by a conversation you overheard in a café.

You tell the story, then ask:

"Have you ever overheard something you really wish you hadn't?"

Suddenly, you've given people something to get involved with.

They don't even have to know your music to join the conversation.

That's active content.


Constantly talking about yourself

I work with independent musicians, and one thing I see quite regularly is a social media feed that looks more like a noticeboard than a place where people gather.


Every post is an announcement.

A new release.

A gig.

A review.

A playlist placement.

Another reminder about the gig.


Now, all those things matter.

But imagine meeting somebody at a party who spends the entire evening telling you what they've achieved.

They tell you about their job, their holidays, their new car and how terribly busy they are.

They never ask you a single question.

Would you want to spend another evening with them?

Possibly. If they'd brought decent biscuits.

But you get my point.


People are far more likely to develop a connection with you when they feel involved rather than simply informed.

And that's particularly important for musicians.

Because you're not just trying to get somebody to listen to a song once.

You're hoping they'll remember you, listen again, follow your journey, buy tickets and perhaps even tell their friends about you.

That takes more than a steady stream of announcements.


How to turn passive posts into active ones

The good news is you don't necessarily need to create more content.


Sometimes you just need to approach the content you're already making a little differently.

Here are a few examples.


1. The new single announcement

Passive: "My new single is out now. Here's the link."

Active: "I wrote this song after somebody told me I was making a terrible mistake. Turns out they were right. Have you ever ignored advice and regretted it?"

You've still got an opportunity to introduce the song, but now there's a story people can relate to.


2. The rehearsal video

Passive: "Rehearsing for Saturday's show."

Active: "We're trying two completely different versions of this song for Saturday. Which one would you rather hear live?"

Now your audience gets to have a say.

And if you actually use their feedback, even better.


3. The behind-the-scenes photograph

Passive: "Back in the studio today."

Active: "We've been arguing about whether this song needs a guitar solo. I say yes. Everyone else says no. Help me out here."

Just make sure it's a genuine debate.

Nobody wants to discover they've spent twenty minutes defending a guitar solo that was never in danger.


4. The live performance clip

Passive: "Great gig last night. Thanks to everyone who came."

More active: "Something happened during this song last night that completely threw me. Watch the drummer's face at the end. Has anything ever gone spectacularly wrong when you've been performing?"

This one works particularly well when there's a genuine story to tell.

The point isn't to tack a question onto everything you post.

It's to find opportunities for your audience to become part of what you're doing.


Not every post needs a question

This is important.


I've seen plenty of advice suggesting that every social media post should end with a question to encourage engagement.

And that can become incredibly tedious.

"Here's my breakfast. What's your favourite breakfast?"

"Here's my guitar. Do you like guitars?"

"Here's a picture of a tree. Have you ever seen a tree?"

Please don't.


People can spot a forced attempt at engagement a mile away.

Sometimes the most effective way to encourage a conversation is simply to tell an interesting story.

  • You might share an embarrassing moment from a gig.
  • An unexpected encounter with another musician.
  • Something you learned while recording your album.
  • Or an opinion that people genuinely want to discuss.


If the content is interesting enough, people may respond without being asked.

And sometimes it's perfectly fine to post something without expecting any response at all.

The goal isn't to manufacture engagement. It's to make your audience feel that they're part of something.


What about the algorithm?

There's a common belief that social media platforms automatically reward posts that ask questions or generate lots of comments. It's not quite that simple.


Platforms use a variety of signals to decide what to recommend, and those signals can vary depending on the type of content and who's watching it.


A post with loads of comments isn't necessarily going to reach more people than one that viewers watch all the way through or share with friends.


And a conversation between you and five genuine fans might be more valuable to your music career than a hundred comments from people who'll never listen to another song.


So I wouldn't create active content simply because you think the algorithm wants it.

I'd do it because building relationships with people who enjoy your music is a good idea regardless of what Instagram decides to do next Tuesday.


Nurturing the conversation

Here's something else musicians sometimes overlook.


Creating content that invites a response is only half the job.

You also need to respond.


If somebody takes the time to leave a thoughtful comment, acknowledge it.

If they ask a question, answer it.

If somebody shares a story that relates to yours, show an interest.


And don't feel you have to turn every interaction into an opportunity to promote your music.

Sometimes a conversation can just be a conversation.

I know. Revolutionary stuff.


The same applies when you're interacting with other people's content.

Find musicians, music lovers and communities that genuinely interest you.

  • Join discussions.
  • Share your opinions.
  • Be helpful where you can.


Not because you're hoping everybody will immediately follow you, but because you're becoming part of a community.

And communities are where some of the most valuable relationships begin.


Turning followers into fans

This is where the whole thing starts to become particularly important.


Getting somebody to follow you is relatively easy compared with getting them to care about what happens next.

They might follow you because they enjoyed one song.

Or because they saw a funny video.

Or because a friend shared something you posted.

But what makes them stay?

What makes them listen to another song?

What makes them buy a ticket?

I think a big part of the answer is connection.


The more somebody feels they know you, understand your music and have a place in your world, the more reasons they have to stick around.

I've explored that idea in more detail in How to Turn Your Followers Into Fans.


And that's why I think active content deserves a place in every musician's social media strategy.

Not because it guarantees more likes.

But because it creates opportunities for relationships that go beyond a single post.


Try this with your next ten posts

Go back and look at the last ten things you've published.


How many simply announced something?

How many told a story?

How many gave people an opportunity to contribute, share an experience or express an opinion?


There's no magic ratio to aim for.

You don't need five active posts and five passive ones.

And you certainly don't need to start asking strangers what they had for breakfast.

Just look for opportunities to make your content a little less one-sided.


The next time you're about to announce a new song, think about the story behind it.

The next time you post a rehearsal clip, consider whether your audience could have a say in what you're working on.

And the next time somebody leaves a comment, see whether there's an opportunity for a genuine conversation.



Because social media isn't just somewhere to tell people what you're doing.

It's somewhere to get to know the people who might want to come along for the ride.

Stop treating your followers like an audience waiting for announcements. Start treating them like people worth talking to.


by Paul Mumford • 16 October 2026
Want your videos to go viral? Discover what really drives views, why reaching the right audience matters and what musicians should focus on instead.
16 October 2026
Struggling to make regular videos for social media? Discover how batch filming can save musicians time and make content creation less stressful.
by Paul Mumford • 13 October 2026
Three scenes, three shots and a freezing barn. Behind the scenes of EM Kane's Wasted Time music video, filmed in just two days.
Show More