How to turn followers into fans

16 September 2026

It doesn't matter what kind of business you run. If you're using social media to promote what you do, you could be missing something important.


Turning followers into fans.

Independent musicians, in particular, can be guilty of this.


  • You post the song.
  • You post the video.
  • You post yourself performing it.

And then... nothing.


There's nothing wrong with posting performance videos. They're an important part of showing people what you do.


But if every post is you performing at people, eventually you're just broadcasting.


If you want followers to become fans, you need to give them a reason to get involved.

Not just watch you.



Here are three simple ways to get your followers talking, rather than just scrolling past.

Catherine Taylor Dawson. Photo by Kyra Mumford ©Monoki Media

Show off your songwriting chops

If you're a songwriter, why not ask your followers to suggest inspiration for your next composition?


You could invite them to come up with:

  • A title for you to work from
  • A subject for your next song
  • Key words or phrases you could include


Now you've got a conversation.

But you've also created something else that's really useful. A reason for people to come back.


Let's say someone suggests the title for your next song. You could then post an update showing how you're getting on. Maybe you've written the chorus. Maybe you've changed the subject completely. Maybe their brilliant idea turned into something absolutely terrible. It happens.


Keep them involved. You could even invite them to a concert or live stream where you perform the finished song for the first time. Suddenly they're not just watching you make music. They're involved in it.


And that's a very different relationship.

Yolera. Photo by Kyra Mumford ©Monoki Media

Musical knockout

Ask your followers to suggest a song for you to cover.


You could just pick your favourite and leave it there. Or you could make it more fun.


Put two songs up against each other and ask your followers to vote.


Then promise to post a video of yourself performing the winning song at the end of the week.


Maybe even do it live. Then take the winner and put it up against another song.


Round two. Then round three.


Before you know it, you've created your own little musical knockout tournament.


The important bit isn't really the voting.

It's the reason to come back. Someone has picked a song. They now want to know whether their song won. So they come back to find out.


I actually use a similar idea for a radio station I manage. They put two songs, artists or albums head-to-head and ask people to choose their favourite. Then they have a reason to tune in at a particular time to find out which one won.


That's the trick.


Don't just give people something to watch. Give them something to look forward to.

Love Itoya. Photo by Kyra Mumford ©Monoki Media

Collaborate

I have to give full credit here to my Instagram friend Semaj Dee who does this regularly.


Gary Barlow also made plenty of collaborative content during the Covid-19 lockdowns, giving people another reason to come back and see who he'd be working with next.


The principle is simple.


Ask another musician to duet, collaborate or play with you on a video. It doesn't have to be complicated. A cover version will do.


For starters, you're meeting new musicians.


But more importantly, their followers get introduced to you and your followers get introduced to them.


That's potentially two audiences discovering something they didn't know existed.


Instagram's Collab feature makes this even easier. You can invite another account to co-author a post or Reel, meaning the content can appear to both audiences if they accept. And suddenly your content isn't only being shown to the people who already know you.


Stop chasing followers. Start building fans.

Here's the bit I really want you to remember.


A follower is just a number until there's a relationship behind it.


If you want those followers to start buying your music, coming to your shows or telling their mates about you, you need to give them a reason to care. And that starts with talking to them.


  • Ask their opinion.
  • Let them influence something.
  • Give them a reason to come back.
  • Show them what's happening behind the music.
  • Let them feel like they're part of the journey.


Because when somebody has helped choose a song, suggested a title or watched something develop, they're no longer just watching a random musician on the internet.


They know a little bit about you.


And that's where a follower can start becoming a fan.


I love helping independent musicians turn attention into actual fans.



If you'd like some help figuring out what to post, how to use video or how to build a marketing plan around your next release, come and have a chat.

Come and have a chat

by Paul Mumford • 16 October 2026
Want your videos to go viral? Discover what really drives views, why reaching the right audience matters and what musicians should focus on instead.
16 October 2026
Struggling to make regular videos for social media? Discover how batch filming can save musicians time and make content creation less stressful.
by Paul Mumford • 13 October 2026
Three scenes, three shots and a freezing barn. Behind the scenes of EM Kane's Wasted Time music video, filmed in just two days.
Show More